For Every Milestone & Holiday

Custom Kosher Cookies

From mitzvahs to birthdays to community celebrations, make your event sweeter and more memorable.

Cookies That Match the Moment

Whether you’re planning a bar or bat mitzvah, hosting a baby shower, celebrating Hanukkah, or organizing a fundraiser, our personalized kosher cookies make every milestone feel special.

Customization Options

Designed for You, Baked by Us

Your love story is unique—your wedding desserts should be too. That’s why
we offer endless ways to personalize your custom kosher wedding cookies:

  • Edible Ink Printing – For names, dates, or Hebrew lettering
  • Frosted Details – To match your event theme
  • Custom Shapes – Shapes tailored to the occasion (from menorahs to balloons)

How to Order

Planning an event takes effort—ordering cookies shouldn’t. Here’s how it works:

Request a Quote

Share your ideas with us by filling out the form below with your details.

Approve & Relax

We’ll send a personalized quote within 2 business days.

Celebrate

Your cookies arrive fresh, safe, and photo-ready.

FAQs

Our custom cookies start at $4.50 per cookie

Yes! Free shipping on orders of 24 or more. We ship every order via USPS Priority Mail, cushioned for safe travel.

Most custom cookie orders take 3–5 business days to produce and ship, with
delivery arriving 2–3 days later.

We recommend ordering at least 14 days before your event. Most custom cookie orders take 3–5 business days to produce and ship, plus 2–3 days for delivery.

Yes! Every cookie we make is strictly certified Kosher Parve. That means they’re welcome at any table—meat, dairy, or parve—and everyone can enjoy them with confidence.

Please note: all custom orders must be placed at least 14 days in advance. 

Our individually wrapped custom cookies start at start at $4.50 each with free standard shipping (minimum order 24 cookies). However, every order is unique and once you fill out the form below we will be able to provide you with a quote within 2 business days.

If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to reach out to us anytime at hello@thekoshercookiecompany.com.

Place your order today for a custom print design on your cookie.

Custom Cookie Examples

Gold Hamilton Broadway Show Star On Kosher Cookie
I Registered to Vote Cookie
Cookie in the shape of a tie-dye shirt
The Friendship Circle Logo On A Cookie
Custom Kosher cookie
Silver Lining Apparel Logo on Cookie
Tray of various kosher sugar cookies with sprinkles on a stainless steel counter top

View Our

Cookie Collections

Check out our wide selection of our cookie tins and packages.

Shop Collection